The second one is my fav. The deep shadow contrasts with the hard side lighting for a nice effect. Top one needs more of that right eye to be really effective. What a great old hat!
The hat and the shemagh are very dear to me. The hat is the last gift I ever received from my father before he passed away. The shemagh was worn by my daughter when she served in Iraq. It still has some bloodstains from when she was wounded in service to our great nation.