thoughts on these :)

[SrBiscuit]

love the shot of banana on string.
not diggin the others.

 

[er111a]

what dont you like about the others?

 

[SrBiscuit]

the treatment in one doesnt add to it for me.
2 is a mediocre pic of a car...so im just not wowed by it.
and 3 is a bed with a selectively colored pillow. again, im just not floored.

but i do like the thought and effort behind the banana. well done.

edit:
i went back and looked again, and i think what it is, is that the 1st 3 dont evoke a single thought from me.
but the banana does. so i think youve really accomplished something there.

 

[er111a]

thanks

 

[bkristopher]

the treatment in one doesnt add to it for me.
2 is a mediocre pic of a car...so im just not wowed by it.
and 3 is a bed with a selectively colored pillow. again, im just not floored.

but i do like the thought and effort behind the banana. well done.

edit:
i went back and looked again, and i think what it is, is that the 1st 3 dont evoke a single thought from me.
but the banana does. so i think youve really accomplished something there.

My thoughts as well...I dig 4 because it was the only one the made me do a "visual/mental double take". Nice!

 

[er111a]

thanks
I actually took about 7-8 different angles of the banana

 

[SrBiscuit]

thats a series.

 

[er111a]

yeah it is

 

[Bitter Jeweler]

thanks tim it was what I was going for

Why? What is your reasoning?

 

[Bitter Jeweler]

thanks tim it was what I was going for

Why? What is your reasoning?

Well?

 

[iAstonish]

thanks tim it was what I was going for

Why? What is your reasoning?

Well?

Don't be a troll.


And I like number 4 a lot. It has a very unique vintage art look. Almost along the lines of contemporary Warhol in the regards of the main subject being such a commodity, yet the image offers a whole different perspective to the usual. Take this comment with a grain of salt, you're no Warhol by any stretch, but even a comparison for critical sake is a great compliment.

 

[SrBiscuit]

i dont think bitter is being a troll.
historically, er1111111a seems to be much quicker to ask questions like "can you tell me why?" than he is to answer them. i think bitter is gently reminding mr. er111a that there's a question to him on the table.

 

[Bitter Jeweler]

Why? What is your reasoning?

Well?

Don't be a troll.

:roll:

And I like number 4 a lot. It has a very unique vintage art look. Almost along the lines of contemporary Warhol in the regards of the main subject being such a commodity, yet the image offers a whole different perspective to the usual. Take this comment with a grain of salt, you're no Warhol by any stretch, but even a comparison for critical sake is a great compliment.

Warhol? You have got to be kidding, right?

 

[er111a]

sorry I didnt get right back to you Bittter right away, To tell you the truth when I was editing them that was just the looked that I wanted for that day, sort of my emotions for that day channeling into my pp

 

[Bitter Jeweler]

Did you take the shot off center and slightly crooked, or did you crop it that way?
What were you trying to ilicit from the viewer with that image?