I'm honestly not too crazy about either. Seems a bit contrived and forced. I see this image, and think "oh, it's artsy"; like college art project artsy. I am left wondering what it's saying exactly. I'm kind of left drawing blanks. It's a strong, bold image - but I kind of feel like it's a strong, bold image for it's own sake.
I do get a sense of loss of identity, vulnerability and gender ambiguity. Perhaps if part of a set dealing with the same themes, the image would make more sense.