Which B&W is better?

[surfingfireman]

Not sure which one I like better. Both converted from colour using PS7.

 

[megapaws]

IMO they are both good... but I prefer the 2nd image just a bit more.... I like the feel of it

 

[AIRIC]

Not sure if it is the laptop or not but the first looks better to me.

Eric

 

[Wally]

I like the first one better, to me the grass in the foreground of the second one keeps on wanting to pull my eye down.

 

[JoeJameson]

I'd have to go with the 2nd one beign the better one, although great job on them both though.

 

[woodsac]

I like both images. But I think the b/w is stronger in #1.

When I scroll the screen and cut off the bottom portion of #2 up to the first shadow where the metal beems are (the lightest area), it really pulls your eyes down the track.

 

[Scarlett_Phoenix]

I prefer the first image, I find the bottom part of the second very distracting.

 

[M @ k o]

Killer shot dude !

 

[Rob]

First one!!

 

[surfingfireman]

Like I figured about 50/50. You guys are a big help! (trying to push the sarcasm through the computer). But seriously, thanks for the comments and Woodsac I see what you are saying when you scroll the screen a bit on #2.