Which do you prefer?

[That One Guy]

I took this picture of my lens cap. I know it's a bit out of focus,but which one looks better?

Color:

or

Black and white:

c&c welcome

 

[Spidy]

All I see is black.

 

[MissMia]

I like the color one! Well done.

 

[quickshot]

Haha. I must say I like your sense of humor. Your "nude photography" joke in another thread made me giggle.

 

[spiffybeth]

i think both pictures are perfect!

im having a hard time deciding which one i like better, but i think im going to have to agree with MissMia.

color!

 

[chantal7]

Lmao. I can't decide... oh my...

Another thing thats funny? In your profile:


Find all posts by That One Guy
Find all threads started by That One Guy
That One Guy is not a member of any public groups
Send a message via email to That One Guy
Send a private message to That One Guy
Add That One Guy to Your Buddy List

 

[LaFoto]

Hmmm. Tough one!
I think I go for the colour version, though, and that looks a bit sharper, too. You somehow focussed better on the centre of your lens cap there!

 

[Renair]

Definitely the colour one, I love what you did with it, the way you can see the details! Very Funny alright!

 

[The_Traveler]

You might consider doing your color conversions using a channel mixer technique. It looks like, from the low dynamic range, that you have simply 'desaturated' your image and that is bad from a technical, not merely an esthetic, consideration.

Also your horizon is off about .8 degrees and I don't like the obvious PSing.

 

[Ajay]

I'm going to go against the flow here and vote for the black and white. Something about it just....speaks to me. Well done!

 

[DragonHeart]

Im with Ajay, I vote for the B&W one.

 

[Steph]

Have you tried HDR on the colour version? I am sure that would make for a better picture. Also consider IR next time.

 

[Mesoam]

ha

 

[The_Traveler]

In looking back at these, your logo really catches my eye. Perhaps reduce it.

I added a little vignetting and some grain effects.

 

[Steph]

Traveler, the post-processing is a bit too obivous in your version. Also, a tighter crop would look better.