Which do you prefer?

woojiebear

TPF Noob!
Joined
Mar 20, 2009
Messages
387
Reaction score
1
Location
Kelowna, B.C.
Can others edit my Photos
Photos OK to edit
Colour or b&w? thanks!

5copy.jpg


5-3.jpg
 
I'd take B&W. In the colour version, the only thing whose colour makes any difference is the sky IMO, which looks great in your B&W conversion anyway.

(Psst, you have some sensor dust near the chimney and on the top left, all over the cloud.)
 
Colour. It has more detail, better exposure and contrast and better tonal control.

skieur
 
Slightly prefer the Black and White, though it does lose a little detail in the darker areas.
 
B&W looks great to me.
 
I say BW as well. But also clean that sensor of yours! and clone out the spots all over the upper left portion of the shot.
 
I prefer the B&W, maby you could brighten some of those problem areas in photoshop.
Oh well heres my attempt, hope you don't mind!
redit.jpg
 
heh thanks! don't mind the edit, no - altho i really like this shot uber-contrasty for some reason.
dang sensor dust...i don't know how to clean it :S i photoshopped it though....
i like the colour too but i decided to go with the b&w...and use THIS colour one instead...

3504768768_4a8cb2a0ea_b.jpg


thanks for the comments! :)
 
I love the Color shot over the Black and white. Something about the crisp colors and the sky with the old and battered house combined.
 
Last edited:

Most reactions

New Topics

Back
Top