What's new

Which QR plate did you choose for your tri-pod / camera - Lenses?

benhasajeep102 100

Been spending a lot of time on here!
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
4,184
Reaction score
626
I have been using Manfrotto's 200PL plates for decades (including some knock off's). I initially thought they were better with the double locking system. And for decades I have never had an unintentional release. But I have also used some Arca Swiss type plates for my big lenses to use on Wimberly gimbal heads. I picked up a new SmallRig video head and have a new Neewer combo tripod (both for no cost to me). They are both Arca. I am thinking of possibly going all Arca and ordering bases for my current Manfrotto heads to change them to Arca.

What do you use for QR's (if you do), for how long, and why did you choose it? And maybe if you also changed styles?
 
I swapped out my Manny ball head with QR2 plates with one that has an Arc Swiss type. Then a couple plates and L bracket. I just wanted something a bit more standard. I guess I had the QR2's for three ir four years
 
I have also been using the Manfrotto 323 RC2 system for decades, including some knock offs. I am not planning on changing, because I have many custom-built items using them.
 
Kessler Quik release and plates. Arca type will fit, but not all of them. But Kessler has some nice plates that work great with their releases. Pricier than Arca. Kessler QR is a double-lock system. I switched after my Gitzo release failed on my Gitzo tripod.

the Kessler Kwik Release Receiver incorporates a two-stage engagement and safety locking system to keep gear secure:

  1. Primary Instant Latch (Drop-Gate Release): When an Arca-Swiss style plate is snapped into the receiver, a spring-loaded red locking bar instantly catches the plate with an audible click. In addition, safety stop pins on official Kessler plates prevent the plate from sliding completely out even before the main lever is closed.
  2. Secondary Cam-Lock Lever: Swinging the main locking lever fully shut engages a heavy-duty cam clamp (rated up to 65 lbs of clamping force), locking the plate tightly into place with zero movement or slip.
To remove the plate, the cam-lock lever must be opened completely, and the red spring bar must be manually pressed inward/downward to fully disengage the gate and release the plate.
 
I’ve used both, but Arca-Swiss is hard to beat for flexibility. Being able to move the same plate between different heads is really convenient.
 
Since I don't have huge lens tonnage, the old small Manfrotto 323 plates and larger hex plates do me just fine.
 
Since I don't have huge lens tonnage ...
I do have some tonnage. My Rokinon 650Z 650-1300mm is both long and heavy, and my Mamiya/Sekor 400mm isn't very heavy, but is fairly long. I don't like physically long lenses putting a strain on my K-70 K mount, so I built a bar to support both body and lens on a tripod, and use it with both lenses. It uses the Manfrotto 323 system to support the lens on the bar, and the bar on the tripod. The 323 plate on the underside is placed to provide decent balance of the bar with any focal length of the Rokinon. I have modified it a little to provide better support for the K-70, and need to take new photos, but these will give you the idea - the second photo shows my old K-1000 body (which needed extra support) because I was shooting with the K-70.

telebar.webp


telebar-a.webp
 
I do have some tonnage. My Rokinon 650Z 650-1300mm is both long and heavy, and my Mamiya/Sekor 400mm isn't very heavy, but is fairly long. I don't like physically long lenses putting a strain on my K-70 K mount, so I built a bar to support both body and lens on a tripod, and use it with both lenses. It uses the Manfrotto 323 system to support the lens on the bar, and the bar on the tripod. The 323 plate on the underside is placed to provide decent balance of the bar with any focal length of the Rokinon. I have modified it a little to provide better support for the K-70, and need to take new photos, but these will give you the idea - the second photo shows my old K-1000 body (which needed extra support) because I was shooting with the K-70.

View attachment 301711

View attachment 301712
Surprising there wasn't a tripod collar made to support that RPG!
 
Surprising there wasn't a tripod collar made to support that RPG!

There is one - it is what the Manfrotto 323 plate is mounted to. The collar consists of two black rings around the body, not a band. The K-70 is a heavy enough body that I don't like to leave it dangling from the back of a lens, especially one extended as far as the Rokinon, not to mention the strain on the Rokinon if fully extended with a camera body. With any lens longer than that which can easily be handled without an added grip I always shoot from a tripod, and the bar was designed for that purpose. I have enough experience with mechanical engineering that I always avoid what I consider unnecessary strain on expensive objects.
 
Last edited:
I returned to this thread because I saw what people are saying about the Arca QR system, but I'm not using it for photography. For nearly a decade I've been using the Manfrotto RC2 QR system (323 receiver and 200-PL plate) for my K-70. I have built four items of custom equipment, with more on the way. I have receivers on my Benro tripod, my Manfrotto tabletop tripod, my Manfrotto monopod, and receivers and plates on my four DIY items. I am locked into the Manfrotto RC2 system for photography, and have been very pleased with it.

I am beginning to work with the Arca QR system for another purpose. I recently purchased a handheld anemometer for measuring air flow in broadcast equipment. That can run from one or two 30-40 CFM muffin fans to a big squirrel cage blower driven by a 240 VAC motor, and delivering 500 to 1,000 CFM.

I need to be able to mount the anemometer anywhere from about six feet off the floor to just above floor level, and oriented vertically or horizontally. I addition, I need to be able to rotate the anemometer 180 degrees on its QR receiver, to use with an air inlet or outlet.

The height range is not difficult - almost any tripod with an invertible center column will do, and it doesn't need to handle more than about a pound of dead load. I have six identical inexpensive light weight compact tripods which I use for purposes such as off-camera flashes. Unfortunately they do not have invertible center columns. I have a few tripods purchased at Goodwill, as well one expensive tripod for the K-70. None of those have invertible center columns.

Switching because vertical and horizontal mounting for the anemometer is easy with a fold-up L bracket. Rotating the anemometer on its bracket is another matter, as my Manfrotto RC2 QR systems (I always have a few receivers and plates on hand) can't do that - the plates only mount one way in the receivers.

I needed a compact tripod with an invertible center column, that need not handle much weight. I also needed a QR system where the plate could rotate 180 degrees in the receiver. I've seen the Arca QR system mentioned many times, and a quick look showed that the plates can rotate 180 degrees. I ended up buying a SIRUI compact tripod with reverse-folding legs, a fluid damped head (my fave), an invertible center column, and a built-in in Arca QR receiver. Their telescoping leg design doesn't look like it will handle a heavy dead load, but it won't have to. It is very compact, and the case is 15" x 4" by 4", small enough to fit in a tote with the anemometer and some accessories. I think I'm going to like the Arca system, but I don't plan to replace all of my Manfrotto RC2 hardware.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom