Dare I post here? Some Christmas card shots- C&C welcome

[transformed]

These are purposefully all a little soft- for the Christmas feel

1.

2.

3

4

 

[AnotherNewGuy]

I think the first one is cool and I like the last one. Saturation or something seems off to me in the second one. I think his face looks flat in third one. I like the catchlights in all of them, but the eyes might be a little soft in a few. I will let the experts do the rest, my C&C might be way off.