IMO, neither is acceptable.
Product photography has got to be spot on. Are you suggesting to be a Sabres fan, a car enthusiast..... and what is on that card? Why is there such a discoloration in your background.
If the second is a business card, you may want to add some more information for your business. You may also want to take another stab at the shot.
HOLY $HIT..... I only watched the last few minutes of VT beating FSU and I left my reply open..... and I was the first reply. Now I way down on the list.
EDIT II:
You changed out the first image. It used to be a lantern with a set of car keys attached.
Tarheels move on in the tournament.......