Definitely seems better re: haloes ... but the second one is a bit muddy ... (I know ... this drives me nuts). I like the third one though ...
Also, remember that you can take one version of the image that has the high contrast/clarity and one without ... pull them into PS into each their own layer ... and use a mask to paint where you want each to show up. Then you can blur the mask and maybe set the opacity of the layer etc, to blend them smoothly ... I've done that with some of my images.