What's new

Alpenglow

How does an image like this get 50 views and not a single comment?

Fantastic image, Majeed – everything clicks. I would consider removing the contrail and also losing about 30% of the sky, but other than that this one's a big winner for me.
 
I like it as it is, contrail and all. Why would you want to remove the contrail? I think that pictures like this get their value from veracity. I also think that a contrail is a perfectly valid compositional element. The contrail was there when the picture was taken, so was the artificially-illuminated wooden rail. Both of those add visual information to the image.

Was it really alpenglow? It looks more like normal last sun.
 
invisible said:
How does an image like this get 50 views and not a single comment?

Fantastic image, Majeed – everything clicks. I would consider removing the contrail and also losing about 30% of the sky, but other than that this one's a big winner for me.

Thanks Federico! I deliberated those 2 very same things. Ultimately decided to leave the contrail since it somewhat echoes the slope of the mountain.

I do have a little room at the top of frame to bring it in a little bit and will explore that. But Probably not very much because one of the key elements of the comp is that tree in the center, which I'd want to leave adequate room..


binga63 said:
you post lovely images and this is another... great shot :)

Thanks thanks!

Helen B said:
I like it as it is, contrail and all. Why would you want to remove the contrail? I think that pictures like this get their value from veracity. I also think that a contrail is a perfectly valid compositional element. The contrail was there when the picture was taken, so was the artificially-illuminated wooden rail. Both of those add visual information to the image.

Was it really alpenglow? It looks more like normal last sun.

Thanks for your comment.

Hmmm, as far as I know it was.. let me know if I'm mistaken.
 
lovely shot, Majeed!
 
How does an image like this get 50 views and not a single comment?

Fantastic image, Majeed – everything clicks. I would consider removing the contrail and also losing about 30% of the sky, but other than that this one's a big winner for me.

I wouldn't know about the first viewers, but sometimes there just isn't anything of great importance to write. For me, either the shot is wonderful, or it is terrible, leaving me with no worthwhile comment.

In this case, the shot is wonderful just as it is. It has good balance, all the technicals are correct, and the frame has good proportions. What is left to say?
 
Great visuals from foreground to background. A+++
 
lovely shot, Majeed!

Thanks Charlie!

I wouldn't know about the first viewers, but sometimes there just isn't anything of great importance to write. For me, either the shot is wonderful, or it is terrible, leaving me with no worthwhile comment.

In this case, the shot is wonderful just as it is. It has good balance, all the technicals are correct, and the frame has good proportions. What is left to say?

Designer, thanks :D

do you have with nothing on the foreground? Love that mountain.. looks like Fujiyama!

Yep, you saw it! :)

Great visuals from foreground to background. A+++

Thanks Fanboy.
 
Nice. Classic scenic-type composition. Yeah, the contrail issue...there are a lot of photographers who absolutely LOATHE them...others not so much...my feeling is that in a scene like this, with the obvious man-made railing, I don't think a contrail is that big of an issue, whatsoever. But to those who loathe "the hand of man" in ANY nature type photo, they would flip out on this shot...

Alpenglow - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
Yeah, the contrail issue...there are a lot of photographers who absolutely LOATHE them...
That'd be me, due to the subjects I usually shoot. I can agree that it's not that big of an issue here, but I believe it doesn't add anything to the composition (even if it doesn't detract much) – if removing it is an easy job, then why not?
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom