I think #2 is not good, but excellent. The lines are superb, you captured a nice texture on the water, and and I love how the angle/light make the water go from dark green to white. The boat is also white, yet you can still see its outline clearly on the white water –great exposure.
I think #1 would of been nice if the framing had the boat vertical in the image instead of somewhat off to the side. I also like #2 as well, lines are pleasing.
