It's not that he would NEED an slr. But anyone who's this into Photography (ie. posting on a photography message board, looking for the the camera with the best options, and already saying he would buy an SLR if he had the money), is just gonna want an SLR later anyway. Why spend that much now on something you're gonna wanna upgrade anyway. Save the money and get what you REALLY want later.
I just spent 2 years waiting for the time I could get a DSLR. You can get used DSLR's for $500 now. Go get a used one if you're low on cash (that's what I did).