Wow, thank you everyone for your help!
in photo 1, that spot is between mom and baby. i'm not sure what that is between them, but the eye was drawn to it. and it loses some detail in the skin tone, which the black and white helps but does not eliminate.
Hmm ok, that was a pillow cus she was sitting on her bed, so I guess I need to watch out a little more carefully for what's in the background.
and in photo number 4, look at the upper right corner. the photo itself is beautiful and i adore the composition, but the bright spot in the corner brings it down a lot for me.
what kind of light source were you using? if it was a strobe, i'd suggest bringing it a foot or so back. and be sure to meter
I was just using natural light since I dont have access to any kind of other lighting equipment at the moment. The window was from that side, so thats why it's a little brighter there. On the left the baby's body is showing through the tutu, so it's darker. I guess this is just another example of watching the background a little more closely haha. Thank you for your input!
3 is my fav, followed closely by 4 (those are sweet baby feet!!)
I want to like the first one but something about the pose isnt working for me. not sure, maybe its cropped too tight? the moms blouse breaks it up I think. would love to see skin-on-skin there, but I know that isnt everyone's thing.
in any case, they are all WAY better than anything I've done. nice job!
Thanks! And yeah, I see what you mean now, I think it might look better if I had included a little more of the moms face, like now that you point it out, it seems really tights around her lip area. Thank you : )
#1 feels a bit busy, would soften the skin tones
#2 definitely soften the skin tones, make them more pink as opposed to red
#3 " " " " " " " " " " " "
#4 like this one, maybe a little too pink (imo)
I tried to smooth out the babys skin tone a little with the clone/healing brushes on photoshop, but I mostly just took care of the little scratches and things that babys get on their faces. When I look at newborn portraits from other people, I can see that it seems like they really smoothed
everything out, but I can imagine using the healing and cloning brush to do every single image from a session would get crazy tedious. Are there any other ways to do it that maybe would make it go faster?
In #1 Mom's OOF and distorted hand in the foreground is distracting. You used 39 mm for your focal length which contributed to the distortion and the OOF foreground from the shallow DOF. As space allows use the longest focal length you can for the best depth-of-field. Many pros like to use 200 mm.
Thanks for going into so much detail! I didnt know about measuring hotspots, Ill have to keep that in mind. Do you think that using aperture (is that the right word?) would have helped too? I read that to make the background blurry I should use a smaller aperture, so used the smallest one I could lol. How do I know what I need to keep the foreground in focus too?
In #3 the infants face seems a bit soft, so that photo may need a bit of sharpening, or mid-tone contrast adjustment.
Yeah, I noticed that too but I didnt know what else to do. I tried sharpening, but I didnt know that mid-tone contrast adjustment would help with that, Ill try that too. Thank you!
