Can't choose (color or B&W)

Unimaxium · Jul 24, 2006

I can't choose between the color and B&W versions of this shot. When I saw the shot I thought it needs a B&W conversion, but I'm afraid that the children blend into the background too much without the color. What do you think? Perhaps I just didn't do a good enough job with the conversion. Also, do you like the crop? I figured the people in the background distract from the main subject so I cut them out. This shot is OTE. Thanks

Here's the B&W:

And the Color:

And the original shot, unedited:

And you can get a higher-res version of the original here for editing:
http://homepage.mac.com/skyboy/whichone/whichonehires.jpg

clarinetJWD · Jul 24, 2006

I know you think the kids blend too much into the BG in B&W, and you're partially right...but...anything is possible in PS, and it seems to me to be a much more classically interesting shot to me in B&W.

Corry · Jul 24, 2006

*ahem* Color.

darin3200 · Jul 24, 2006

B&W, but maybe try to get the kids to standout more from the BG

Peanuts · Jul 24, 2006

Half and half? (What help am I?)

malweth · Jul 25, 2006

Half and half might work well... put the BG in B+W and leave the kids in color.

ksmattfish · Jul 25, 2006

I like the color version better, but the BW version looks okay too. My version of "half-n-half" would be to reduce color saturation by 50%. That would make the background very close to monchrome (it's already much closer than the kids), and tone down the bright colors of the kids' clothing.

JJP · Jul 25, 2006

Give selective colouring a go hehe, if that looks crap, I think you should go with colour, the kids blend into the background with b&w.

markc · Jul 25, 2006

As they are now, I prefer the color, but I'd probably prefer the b&w if you spent some time using a selective layer to brighten up the kids a little bit. Just a touch to make them pop from the background more.

I'd also crop the right off so that the gate is centered. Normally you don't want to center things, but here the symmetry works well and makes is easier for my eyes to pop to the kids.

henryhurrry · Jul 25, 2006

I really like what color does to the stone sidewalk. You nee to increase the saturation for the chilldren a bit, using lasso tool, to make them stand out a bit better.

Daniel · Jul 26, 2006

I aggree with markc, crop out the right side, so the gate is centered. And I prefer the b/w version, it just needs a bit more work, so the kids pop out a bit.