Can't Deicde between these 2 photos.

Wilson1990 · Feb 11, 2008

Cropped.

Uncropped.

Help?

itsanaddiction · Feb 11, 2008

neither - too much wasted space

lifeafter2am · Feb 11, 2008

I agree, both of them have too much wasted space. I understand what you are going for, but there is just tooooo much empty space.

ashadiow · Feb 11, 2008

Honestly, take the wide one, and crop it a little beyond the top of the antenna. You will have a wide pano look to it and I think it will be awesome!

Wilson1990 · Feb 11, 2008

lifeafter2am · Feb 11, 2008

Much better.

That One Guy · Feb 11, 2008

lifeafter2am said:
Much better.

agreed

Wilson1990 · Feb 11, 2008

Cheers!

passerby · Feb 11, 2008

The victim of only fixed lens.

If you do have zoom lens the outcome would be pleasant photo to look at, and no need cropping, agree?

SBlanca · Feb 12, 2008

by fixed lens do you mean a P&S camera? if so, how would you know he has used one...just curious

passerby · Feb 12, 2008

SBlanca said:
by fixed lens do you mean a P&S camera? if so, how would you know he has used one...just curious

Pure guesing. The way the picture was composed as though he could not get any closer. Other posters comments were it is to much waste of space. So I assume it was a fixed lens in a location where he could not get any closer. It came accross me that situation where my zoom was not long enough to create good composition.

Of course unless - if that is the composition he had in mind before he pressed the shutter button, than we are all wrong.

leila · Feb 12, 2008

too much sky in both

Wilson1990 · Feb 12, 2008

passerby said:
Pure guesing. The way the picture was composed as though he could not get any closer. Other posters comments were it is to much waste of space. So I assume it was a fixed lens in a location where he could not get any closer. It came accross me that situation where my zoom was not long enough to create good composition.

Of course unless - if that is the composition he had in mind before he pressed the shutter button, than we are all wrong.

You're right and wrong.

It's not a fixed lens, it's an 18-55mm but it was zoomed all the way out to 55mm and I couldn't get any closer for the angle/composition I wanted.

Big Wallaby · Feb 13, 2008

It's great cropped. Lends some nice detail, yet for some of the purposes for which I shoot (like backgrounds for presentations, etc), this would work well... though the wide look stands well on its own, too.