2 and 3 get my "yes". The last a "maybe +", as I really like the colours, but prefer to see more of that glorious sky which we do see in 2.
In my estimation (which, of course, is highly subjective), the two vertical frames fall a bit short. 1 is a clear "no" to me.
Cool, thanks guys My personal favorite is number two. Number 4 I cropped from the original, since it had a bunch of foreground. If only I would have aimed the camera a little higher it would have been good (D'oh!)
By the way, these were taken in New Jersey...who says Jersey can't be beautiful! (Now that I said that, it was probably the pollution and toxic gases causing the colors :lmao
#1 The sky seems blown out, other than that I like it though. This photo had a lot of potential in my opinion. I am no expert on HDR, but this seems like a good time for it maybe? Any of you HDR guys care to comment on this?
#2 Yes, I like it a lot.
#3 No, I dont like the composition really.
#4 No, It looks pretty noisy and I find that discrating and it takes away from the beauty of the image.