Difference between learning color and b&w photography

[ann]

But if you look at the images, they weren't at the same angle, which will make changes in the metering decision that was made by the camera not the human.. ALso, not to be rude to naptime, everything may not be the same, altho, i understand he thought so.

Just take a closer look at the images posted, they don't even look like the same focal length lens was used.

Also, if both rolls of film were developed together at the same time that should not be a factor with the underexposure issue. Scanning is a different story.

 

[naptime]

both were scanned on the same scanner. but it's not a film scanner. so that can certainly be a factor.

both were developed at the same time in the same tank. unlikely that's a factor.

but yes, definitely not the same angle. she was was also wider, and focused more to the left. i was zoomed in more, and focused more to the right.



****many apologies to the op for the threadjack.

 

[c.cloudwalker]

I know how black and white should be done but usually it is done to hide mistakes that would show up in colour.

:thumbdown:

Trust me, I know I am somewhat taking you out of context but this whole post just reminds me what kind of a joke you are. Go back to your TV studio.

 

[enzodm]

But if you look at the images, they weren't at the same angle, which will make changes in the metering decision that was made by the camera not the human.. ALso, not to be rude to naptime, everything may not be the same, altho, i understand he thought so.

Just take a closer look at the images posted, they don't even look like the same focal length lens was used.

Also, if both rolls of film were developed together at the same time that should not be a factor with the underexposure issue. Scanning is a different story.

since we are on a learning thread, I continue on this.
Naptime told "we did not know about metering. we had the sunny 16 chart, and with my limited understanding, this is what we came up with. iso 100 film, shutter 90, and f11". So, no camera metering. Unless one of them set something different instead of that, exposure is the same.
By the way, I see difference in contrast more than in exposure, but I do not know what may cause it in development.