eddit'd a photo, what do you think

phil-ray · Nov 22, 2006

I was asked to eddit a photo for a guy on another forum. what do you think?

he hasnt seen it yet as i thought i would show it here befor sending it to him. C and C welcome

orgional

woodsac · Nov 22, 2006

The sky is more washed out than in the original. The red's and green's seem over-saturated now. You've also lost some detail in the shadows. Might benefit from about a 1* ccw rotation?

I'm not trying to sound negative, just telling you what I see.

phil-ray · Nov 22, 2006

Cheers dude, ill get on to the suggestions.

sometimes i think my monator on my laptop is not the same as some others.

phil-ray · Nov 22, 2006

heres the pic eddited a bit, still need to do a bit of noise reduction and the blue in the middle is a bit strong,

ClarkKent · Nov 22, 2006

Nice edititing

oldnavy170 · Nov 22, 2006

I actually like the first edit more but thats because I really love the bright colors. YOu did an amazing job!!!! You can edit my photos anyday!!!!!!

phil-ray · Nov 23, 2006

cheers guys, i like edding photos, i wish i was not as lazy as i am then i would eddit more of mine lol.

i like the first eddit better but the guy didnt want it that bright.

oldnavy, if u have a photo feel free to pm me and ill try and eddit it for u if u ever want

Big Mike · Nov 23, 2006

The first one is a little too much for me. The 2nd one looks better IMO...but the blues are just a little to saturated compared to the rest.

gizmo2071 · Nov 23, 2006

I'm with Woodsac.
I'd probably try and level the horizon/bridge a little.
I'm not to keen one the first edit. I think it's over saturatded and just looks wierd to my eye.
Did a better job with the brick and grass on the second edit. Then you coloured the water in blue, which again I'm not to keen on.
Sorry.
I'd have gone for a simple rotate and crop and slight colour edits. Nothing to much

Good job tho