Okay, well I'm also not really the best for hair advice--after all, look at what MINE does!
<<<<<<<<<< LOL
Seriously, I'm one of those women who just doesn't care much about all the typical "girly" stuff. My last haircut was right at a year ago--before that? I hadn't had it cut in FIVE years! Not even trimmed!
My two top picks have pretty much been eliminated; I liked the first one and the middle one, but someone said the first takes a lot of effort to maintain, and the middle requires more hair volume than it sounds like you have.
Do you have any good beauty schools near you? I use the Aveda Institute and the first time I went I just asked their advice on a style that would look good on me and work well for my facial structure, maintenance requirements, etc.
8 or 9, though the only difference I see is that 9 is a tad shorter. I also tend to only get my hair cut about once a year and it is long, straight and very fine and won't do anything but hang there. I keep thinking of hacking it all off but my Mom always made me keep my hair very short as a kid since she "doesn't believe in long hair" so now I always keep it long.
Before my grandmother passed away in 2001, I had only ever let my hair grow long ONCE. She hated it, said my face was too thin and small for long hair. I hated it too, because back then my hair was still really thick and much brighter red--with a little humidity, it would start "poofing" out and I'd end up looking like Ronald McDonald in street clothes.

After she died, I grew it long again. Not because she wasn't around, but because by that time my mother could no longer see that well to cut it (yes, my mother cut my hair, and yes, I was 40 years old at the time!! At that point, I'd only had ONE "professional" haircut in my adult life, when I got married).
I found that the volume had thinned enough that it no longer tends to do its Ronald McD thing, plus time (and calories) have lent a little more "weight" to my facial structure, so I liked it better. Kept it long for the next decade plus.
I'm probably the wrong woman to respond to this, but I'll add my two cents.

I'm not a fan of any, but only because I don't like any hair style that's long enough to constantly fall out in my face. Short to the ears cuts are my favorites. No muss, no fuss, wash, towel dry, finger comb, and go.
Me too! I'm back to shorter hair now, and love it! Wash it, towel it dry (you do NOT want to see what a blow dryer does to these curls!! lol), scrunch it up a few times and I'm good to go.