New to photography and would love some C&C

[Jeanelle]

1.

2.

3.

 

[reznap]

I like them. Any reason you converted all of them to (very warm) black and white?

I'd lose the vignette on the top of #1 and subdue it a bit or lose it completely on #3.

#2's a nice composition... great photo overall. The other two look 'average' next to it.

 

[Derrel]

I'd agree that #2 is a great photo overall, and that it makes #1 and especially #3 look 'average' by way of comparison. Photo #3, the two girls hugging, is poor. The first photo is so-so...kind of okay, yet...it doesn't quite have the polished look of #2.

 

[Jeanelle]

I think that it was just a fluke that I picked all the "same" type of edits. I try to keep them varied, but like the b&w and sepia a lot. I will try your suggestions, and thanks so much for the help!

 

[Jeanelle]

I'd agree that #2 is a great photo overall, and that it makes #1 and especially #3 look 'average' by way of comparison. Photo #3, the two girls hugging, is poor. The first photo is so-so...kind of okay, yet...it doesn't quite have the polished look of #2.

Thanks so much for all the help, this is my first time to post on a forum. I love to hear what others think of my photos!

 

[burgo]

I don't dig the first one. The second one is excellent but you could crop the top more. I agree with the vignette of the 3rd - lose it or back it off a lot. otherwise well done

 

[Jeanelle]

Thanks burgo, I am loving hearing what people think!

 

[Jeanelle]

Ok, sorry to sound foolish, but I am having a really hard time trying to find where you post new threads. Obviously I found it once, but that took forever, and now I can't find it again! Can someone help me please???

 

[NikonNewbie]

right above the top of the threads page on the left...skinny rectangular bar.

 

[Jeanelle]

Thanks!!!