BananaRepublic
No longer a newbie, moving up!
- Joined
- Jul 10, 2014
- Messages
- 1,319
- Reaction score
- 161
- Location
- Eire
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
there is never any kind of advice or tutorials given to rectify the problems which would or should improve the whole groups images mine included.
there seems to be a kind of cold war attitude amongst the better people.
In my experience (three camera clubs over the years) they fixate on competitions and on certain technical flaws and there often seems to be little else going on. In one competition one of the member judges gave most of the images a very low score based on the fact that they were "not sharp," which means they did not look perfectly sharp when projected at a size of about four feet on the long side and viewed by him from about four feet away. In my opinion this quest for ultimate sharpness is foolish because many wonderful images that will appear perfectly sharp as 11x14 prints viewed at arm's length will be tossed out in favor of images that appear equally sharp as prints but look a little sharper projected, even if the former are better images in terms of composition, etc.
They also tend to think of composition in terms of "rules," of which they have about five or six, some of which are not consistent with what you can read about composition in some of the classic books on the subject. It may help to take a little break from that environment and go shoot what you want how you want.
It makes me very sad to hear about the "cold war" thing - the club I am in currently, for all its flaws, does not have this problem.
I use the phrase "Its cut your own throat sharpe" .