Rate the photo above you

[Bo4key]

I agree with you about the dark spot in the middle of the face, and the detail seems washed out to me.

6/10


Orange Burst by Boaketography, on Flickr

 

[Bend The Light]

Lovely tones in the flower. I like the fact it is muted tones, too. Only thing is the leaves need to be muted around it to make it stand out...some of the edges of leaves are brighter than the flower, drawing the eye... 8/10, though, as I love the flower.

Something a little different...a series of photos...

drip drip bigger by http://bendthelight.me.uk, on Flickr

 

[Tigertail]

6 or 7/10 Definitely an interesting arrangement. I think technically it is very well done however it doesn't do much to inspire me artistically in a sense.

 

[kundalini]

7/10 - I like the leading lines of the reflected tree trunks and the way they frame the subject. Good separation from the background. Nice capture of a pensive mood. Very square to the camera emphasizing a flat look.

For the participants in this thread, please have a look at this thread. Your thoughts will be appreciated.

http://www.thephotoforum.com/forum/...ar-thread-good-idea-rate-photo-above-you.html

 

[MWC2]

great bokeh, cute subject, nice and sharp. I'm giving it a 8/10 (honestly if it was a cute little kitten or puppy I'd bump it to a 9.5/10)

I'm still a noob but here is mine for rating.

 

[Cfitz]

Interesting subject, and good focus and sharpness on him. Good composition as well. The only thing wrong is the background. It's very busy and the house or building is very distracting. 6/10

 

[gsgary]

Nice and sharp, but why did you shoot it lanscape and not portrait

Oh **** too late disregard this post

 

[Starskream666]

Very cute, quite powerful 7/10

Sorry to side track, but I love this image!I :heart: the color manipulation, the blues and purples against the golds. It totally reads as a spot of fantasy, boy surround by visible daydreams...walking into Narnia. This image has story power and evokes emotion. 10+/10.Ignore Traveler, this time!

Aw thanks alot man, that means alot coming from you

 

[yoodontknomi]

The horse shot is really great! Its sharp and the action is nicely frozen! I wish there wasn't so much room on the left, but I understand the scene was probably going very quickly.

This is a shot I took way back in 2007 for a college class with a 5 mp kodak easy share. Saw it in the woods. This is straight from camera, as I don't have post-processing skills yet.

 

[Tigertail]

9.7/10 Love the overall ambience the lighting and droplets convey. It evokes some feeling that is absolutely gorgeous in my opinion! I want it as my desktop image.

 

[Compaq]

When I look at this empty street, I get the feeling I think you wanted me to feel. Walking alone on a beach following a trail. It has a really nice calm to it. I want to say that it's side lighted by a low, red sun, but I can't really see any shadows confirming that - those shadows would have been nice.

I feel the building is slightly distracting, the one on the left. It takes my eyes away from the girl and the trail. I'll give it a 8.



IMG_0422_edited-1 by Bokehliciousness-ness, on Flickr

I'm gonna try getting a response on this photo in here Cheating? maybe so

 

[yoodontknomi]

I really like it, I know you posted it in another thread but ill respond here.
I usually dont find much interest in flower pictures, but the Jesus face minus the beard is interesting.
I agree with your sentiments about the focus on the top pedals, but overall, a really cool image with good bokeh action, and I love bokeh.

This image was taken in 2007 in a college class, straight from camera. I wasn't aware of the rule of thirds and such, so I know the composition is a bit off.

 

[wwall]

I was waiting on someone else to take this one beause I really can't think of anything good or bad to say about it... 6/10 - it just isn't very interesting. (This is coming from a complete noob though.)


DSC_0153-1 by wwall3, on Flickr

 

[TCD photography]

6/10. Something bugs me about this shot. I'm by no means an expert, but it feels too straight on, being directly over the petal facing you. Either left or right, between the two petals would have been better.

 

[lyonsroar]

Fake reflection or real reflection? It looks fake to me.
Not very sharp. Looks like a heavy crop.

5/10




Not a Single F**k was given that day by Lyonsroar91, on Flickr