I like the perspective and composition of the first shot.
Yes, the bottom of the rose is cut off, but I still think it is a great photo.
I really like the fencing as a background, very urban feeling!
Thanks for all the comments. I'm actually a little surprised that everybody prefers the first one... I guess something in me reacts agains the classic flower closeup. The image isn't cropped; I'll be watching out for that cutoff next time.
I really like the fencing as a background, very urban feeling!