Although I prefer the composition/pose/feel of #1, the blow outs kill it. The right hand melts into the blownout background as well as the collar of the jacket. But on second/third look, it's also pretty cool. Where we can (at times) melt into the background, oblivious from others of our woes. Scrolling back up a few times, I actually like #1.
#2 :meh: I dislike mobile phones to a large extent.