What's new

This is a great video about DSLR's versus Mirrorless

I don't find many of my adapters are heavy (probably similar to the difference in weights of lenses) and making use of adapters my mirrorless cameras have a MUCH wider selection of lenses available than any DSLR (particularly a Nikon one which can't use without adding optics any of the 10000s of M42 lenses available for peanuts, Canon/Pentax DSLRs can use these fine).

I also don't find the mirrorless cameras have me less involved in the ordinary selection of settings.

In general I find my mirrorless cameras are better in low light, when very high burst rates are wanted, at adapting lenses and (after conversion) with non visual wavelengths - when the viewfinder shows what the sensor sees.
My DSLRs are slightly better for action shots - I guess it must be down to slight viewfinder lag, but it might be partly down to the lenses I have for each.

For most shooting including the sorts of shots he's taken either is quite capable.
 
I will stick with my Canon DSLR's. I've been shooting for over 60 years, moved to digital in 2010, not moving to mirrorless. I don't want/need a camera that does 'everything' for me. I shoot 'Manual' mode most of the time, as I was trained so many decades ago ... so, I pick the ISO*, f-stop, and shutter, based on the subject, lighting, and the image that I want to capture.
*Was 'ASA' when I began.
 
I have six cameras now (too many I know and it's a long story), all six are mirrorless and no possible way would I ever consider returning to use a DSLR. I watched the video and the vidiot who made it failed to mention the two reasons I would never consider going back to using a DSLR.

Reason 1: I bought my first mirrorless camera 13 years ago not because I wanted a mirrorless camera but because it was the only option that was available to use with the lens I bought. My mentor who taught me photography many decades ago taught me rule #1: lenses take photos and cameras hold film (sensors). If you're shopping for a camera first and lens second you're being stupid. 13 years ago when I was ready to make a change I went shopping for the lenses I wanted. I found the 14mm f/2.8 Fuji lens and bought it, the camera that came with it happened to be mirrorless. I now have 3 wide angle lenses that are entirely free of distortion -- not an option for a DSLR because of the mirror. The reduced flange distance in mirrorless cameras allows for superior lens designs especially in the wide angle range which is most important to me. As an added advantage I can use almost all of my lenses on all of my cameras with appropriate adapters. My M mount 35mm f/2 Biogon is magnificent and works on all of my cameras. It would not work on any DSLR. I will never go back to a DSLR.

Reason 2: The vidiot noted the mirrorless camera option for a WYSIWYG viewfinder (not a DSLR option). Heaven forbid that I would ever want to set an exposure that produced a good camera JPEG, but, the live-view exposure aids in a mirrorless camera (specifically the highlight alert function) have changed the way I use my cameras and allow me to set a precise sensor exposure with an ease and accuracy that was not possible using a DSLR. I would never give up that added precision and go back to using a DSLR.
 
I fully understand why people do not upgrade their DSLR to Mirrorless as they have investment in lenses and bodies that do everything they need and often more.

What i don't understand is why someone new coming into the photography world would not want to upgrade to the newer systems when they don't have to worry about upgrading their entire gear etc.

Now granted their are often deals on DSLR's so Mirrorless might cost you a touch more upfront , however you are also upgrading to the newest technology that changed for a reason.

I went Mirrorless a few years ago and will never look back.
 
I now have 3 wide angle lenses that are entirely free of distortion -- not an option for a DSLR because of the mirror.
Are you talking about viewfinder distortion?
 
Are you talking about viewfinder distortion?
No, optical distortion: "Remarkably, there is no distortion at all for images shot with the 14mm f/2.8 R." Fujinon XF 14mm f/2.8 R - Imaging Resource

Wide angle lenses for SLR cameras have to clear the mirror and that requires a radical retrofocus lens design: Angénieux retrofocus - Wikipedia Beating the optical distortion out of a retrofocus lens is a near impossible task and so finding a comparable wide angle lens for a DSLR with basically zero distortion like the Fuji 14mm f/2.8 is a very tall order.
 
What i don't understand is why someone new coming into the photography world would not want to upgrade to the newer systems when they don't have to worry about upgrading their entire gear etc.
If I were new to photography, I may be tempted to get the newest gear, but it might not be as accessible to me as used DSLR cameras and lenses and that would make me look into those as a good place to start and as upgrade options. Even as a veteran to the craft I still opt for DSLR cameras and lenses because they are more accessible, and I also know that I don't need the newest tech to create excellent work. Honestly, I upgraded from an original Canon 5D that I had been shooting with since 2011 to a Canon 5D MKIII in 2022, and I still absolutely love that MKIII and haven't felt a need to upgrade it since getting it, and when I do finally upgrade, it will likely be to a used 5D MK IV instead of a mirrorless. Some newbies may also understand that they also don't need the newest tech in order to learn, or they may be dipping their toes into photography as a new hobby so they don't want to invest too much into it right away, and that could also be the reason why they'd choose DSLR over mirrorless.
 
Last edited:
I will stick with my Canon DSLR's. I've been shooting for over 60 years, moved to digital in 2010, not moving to mirrorless. I don't want/need a camera that does 'everything' for me. I shoot 'Manual' mode most of the time, as I was trained so many decades ago
Same here, call me suspicious but could the mirrorless hype a marketing way to loop people into buying more stuff?

I really think companies like Canon and Nikon would give bodies at cost away just so they can sell lens's.
 
Eh I feel like the guy in the video is trying to make the Mirrorless to DSLR the same as the old drama of film to Digital.

First up the adaptors for Mirrorless to use old DSLR lenses are typically just a hollow tube. They add practically no weight at all and the only problem with them is remembering to leave them on the camera when swapping DSLR lenses or bringing them with you in the first place when taking a mix of two lens types out at once. Both basically just minor things. So the whole "adding weighty adaptors" to me sounds like he's just scaremongering for the sake of it.
Once you've got an adaptor - BOOM - you've got all the same lenses the DSLR could use on mirrorless plus all the mirrorless lenses as well. Now one valid argument here is with more advanced 3rd party lenses where I have heard that some focus/anti-shake systems in their lenses can come into conflict with anti-shake systems built into mirrorless cameras. From what I can gather its a bit "case by case" and you can always turn off anti-shake systems to get around this. This is basically getting into the grounds though of specific lens and camera body combos and limits. Broadly speaking the mirrorless has a vast range of lenses to choose from.
Honestly I'm surprised how much DSLR gear has gone down in value second hand or hasn't gone up. Mirrorless can use them and at the very least ownbrand work with zero issues and mirrorless replacements are not cheap. So why DSLR have tanked really surprises me; honestly that's the real marketing trick in convincing people that mirrorless really is this whole "new" thing that's so different

Exposure wise the mirrorless doesn't have to preview exposure, you can turn that off. Heck I prefer to have it turned off as that provides a clearer picture to focus and compose with and which isn't distracting you with jumping around on exposure. Of course I tend to shoot more action stuff or macro so having a clear image is more important to me (esp if my settings are setup for flash where the exposure in camera would be under-exposing). If you're shooting landscapes or portraits without flash, the yes the predictive exposure would be far more useful. And you can easily use a custom menu to add the toggle for this setting so you can access it quickly (custom menus having been in DSLRs for utterly ages too so nothing new there)

All the "bells and whistles" of mirrorless are no different to DSLRs. It's just a general steady advance of features and functions that you can turn off; turn on; custom menu control and so on and so forth. Yes it means reading the manual; watching a few videos and getting to grips with new features and ideas, but its no different to DSLRs. If anything its more just going from "entry level simple camera" to "intermediate/advanced camera" differences.

He also ignored the AF - AF is freaking black magic with mirrorless. Not just more AF points; there's the whole eye/subject detection system that mirrorless have going for them; something that, when it works, can free your composition up considerably and speed you up. Esp when shooting action where you don't always have time to play with the joystick to move your AF point around the screen between fast moving shots. Yes its got limits; yes it has problems of its own; yes setting up duel backbutton AF takes watching a 10minute video on it; but its so powerful!



Personally I went from a 7D to a R6MII and I've not looked back. The camera just freaking WORKS so well. The only downside I can find really is that it burns through battery power a LOT faster even with a battery grip; and that issue is resolved by just picking up a few more batteries.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Back
Top Bottom