window VS flash- Can you tell which are which?

[JustJazzie]

Babys reshoot was yesterday, and while it went better than our first go- he still wasn't having it! He gave me about 25 minuets of light sleep, which made posing a slow process. After those precious minuets he was DONE. In the end, I was able to give her a set of about a dozen. Only 3-ish of which I thought were up to par.

Anyways, I thought it would be fun to see how my lighting skills are coming along, by seeing who can guess which of these were flash/strobe, and which were natural light.

PS- Im on a 2007 macbook, and number three is looking magenta. Hows it look on your end?

Cheers!


1)

2)

3)

4)

 

[astroNikon]

my guess
1) flash
2) flash
3) window (background color)
4) flash

 

[JustJazzie]

my guess
1) flash
2) flash
3) window (background color)
4) flash

You got 2/4!

 

[Tim Tucker]

I'd go with 2 as natural light.

 

[JacaRanda]

Eyes open flash, eyes closed natural?

 

[ronlane]

1 & 3 natural (window) and 2 & 4 are flash.

 

[robbins.photo]

Ok, well I think something was missed in all of this.. some introductions are in order here.

People, meet Demon Spawn, Demon Spawn, welcome to TPF.

Lol.. ok, there. Much better.

 

[cherylynne1]

I'll guess....

1. Flash
2. Window
3. Flash
4. Flash

And I agree, 3 looks slightly off from the others. Not enough for me to call it wrong, but in a set it definitely stands out. I think they look great, though!

 

[astroNikon]

my guess
1) flash
2) flash
3) window (background color)
4) flash

You got 2/4!

But that's what your Flickr EXIF stated !!

 

[ronlane]

my guess
1) flash
2) flash
3) window (background color)
4) flash

You got 2/4!

But that's what your Flickr EXIF stated !!

Nope, according to that it is #1 Flash, #2 No flash, #3 No flash, #4 Flash

 

[JustJazzie]

my guess
1) flash
2) flash
3) window (background color)
4) flash

You got 2/4!

But that's what your Flickr EXIF stated !!

But my camera doesn't register when I have a strobe hooked up for some reason, only OCF. I knew someone would try to cheat. ;-)

 

[astroNikon]

my guess
1) flash
2) flash
3) window (background color)
4) flash

You got 2/4!

But that's what your Flickr EXIF stated !!

Nope, according to that it is #1 Flash, #2 No flash, #3 No flash, #4 Flash

yup you're right now that I recheck that.
It must have been flickr changing things or I was in too much of a hurry comparing what I though and what flickr had.

• ƒ/1.8

• 50.0 mm

• 1/160

• 180

• Flash (on, fired)

 

[JustJazzie]

Drum roll please!.....

1,3&4 all strobe
2 is window light

I'd go with 2 as natural light.

Congratulations Tim, you are the WINNER!

 

[JustJazzie]

I'll guess....

1. Flash
2. Window
3. Flash
4. Flash

And I agree, 3 looks slightly off from the others. Not enough for me to call it wrong, but in a set it definitely stands out. I think they look great, though!

Somehow I missed this one! Good job, another winner!

I'll retouch that third one before I had it over for sure! Thank you!

 

[cherylynne1]

I'll guess....

1. Flash
2. Window
3. Flash
4. Flash

And I agree, 3 looks slightly off from the others. Not enough for me to call it wrong, but in a set it definitely stands out. I think they look great, though!

Somehow I missed this one! Good job, another winner!

I'll retouch that third one before I had it over for sure! Thank you!

Yay! I thought the fall-off looked different! Somebody give me a cookie!