So I think these photo are very good, but I also see where people are coming from with the whole 'racy' thing. And I don't thin that many people are saying that on the grand scale of prude vs the sexual revolution, that these are racy, but just in terms of what someone would expect from a senior photos. If you asked 100 people to imagine a senior portrait, I don't think any of them would come up with something like this. And on the same token, if you showed these to 100 people and asked them what their purpose was, I don't think many people would guess senior portrait. Does that make them wrong or inappropriate? NO. Just makes them different than expected. If the client loves them and that's what they wanted, than you did a great job.
I think the girl, dress, poses and lighting are all gorgeous. Great job there. I think majority of the foreground scenery is very nice, but a lot of the backgrounds have distracting elements to them. To me they look like they belong in a bridal catalogue. And that's probably more of a compliment than a critique. Great job overall.