- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 4,700
- Reaction score
- 5,183
- Location
- Long Island, New York
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
I agree, in general, that the book is better than the movie, BUT one counterexample is The Godfather. I thought the movie was wonderful, but the book was almost unreadable. Whoever first saw that movie in that book was a creative genius. BTW, on a photography note, some of the footage of the Don's daughter's wedding was taken from actual movies shot at mafia weddings. I could tell you how I know, but I'd have to kill you.The wife and I saw A Walk in the Woods yesterday. If you want a comedy with lots of cliched jokes, fat shaming/jokes, drunk jokes, and whatnot, go see it. It had its moments. If you read the book, you'll notice some differences. I think the biggest part that annoyed me in the movie was that they were on the trail for many miles, and their bodies/boots/gear showed essentially no signs of wear. That was a disappointment to me.
Morning, hosers!
I wasn't really interested in seeing that movie, but now I have even less interest. The book was good - Bryson is an entertaining writer while still presenting real information. I think it was a bad idea to begin with to make a movie out of the book.
Ed, I'll be down in an hour or so with a bib on!
So I was really good about staying away from triggers but alas, the headache found me anyway Hopefully it won't be too bad this time.
I thought about going to see it--but I ended up deciding to just re-read the book instead. I really like Redford, so that was the main attraction to me as far as seeing the movie. But I'm not much of a Nick Nolte fan (although I can definitely see him as Katz--he does blundering annoyance pretty well). As I'm re-reading it, I keep thinking, how in the blazes would they make all this commentary--which is what really completes the book--anything that could translate to a movie?
I haven't seen a whole lot of movies based on books where the movie was actually better than the book.
Well, comic books maybe.. but not actual books. Lol