2 photoshop actions - which one?

[amnd2323]

I was playing with photoshop actions on this portrait. Please critique and let me know which one you like better...thanks!

 

[AgentDrex]

I like the second one as it is a tad darker and is a little less yellow than the first one...

 

[katy625]

See, I like the warmer tone of the first pic. The second pic has to much of a green washed out hue to me. Have u tried this in b&w yet? It may look really good with the light in his face and the shadows surrounding him.

 

[EhJsNe]

Is there an in between? Both are a little much. I prefer the first one though, it makes the kid seem more cute, the second one seems like something you'd do to a more serious portrait.

I agree with katy on the black and white thing

 

[dak1b]

i think i wud like the picture right in between these edits.

 

[swmocity]

i like the second one better

 

[amnd2323]

Here's a B&W version...

 

[er111a]

black and white is my favorite

 

[dak1b]

black and white is my favorite

ditto!:thumbup:

 

[cajunbandmom]

wow I like the childs eyes in the b & w one

 

[BuS_RiDeR]

The Black and White is my favorite. His eyes are great!

Too bad his cheeks are blown out...

 

[Dominantly]

At first, I liked the warmer version best, but then after looking at it carefully I decided I didn't like the neck regions color, and the color lining the cheek.

 

[ckboucher]

B&W...for sure.

 

[katy625]

I love the b&w!!!

 

[AgentDrex]

Yup, that was a B&W waiting to happen...