Interesting images. Where were they taken and what is that object trapped in the ice?
WesternGuy
This is the Portage Glacier, in Alaska. In the summer it's only accessible by tour boat, but in the winter you can hike a few miles across the frozen lake to reach it. The second photo is a shale pebble, about 1" square.
The first one could use a bit of exposure correction, and the image could be a little sharper in my opinion.
Here's what I would do.
View attachment 134240
A bit of clarity; boosted shadows; brought down highlights; high pass sharpening; and a bit of dodging/burning.
Thanks for working on this, Daryll. I think your edit is a lot more dramatic and interesting to look at than mine. I'm still a novice in LR, but I had already adjusted this image to my "reality limit", and I guess I should have included some details in my first post. I took the highlight slider to zero, shadow slider to 100, and adjusted the blacks and whites to just short of clippping. I used a grad filter to bring down the sky's exposure to match the foreground a little better, and I used split toning to increase the sunset colors in the sky and reflections off the snow/ice. Your edit is beautiful, and does make me think about the balance between accurately depicting the subject and creating art with visual impact.