Columns: B&W vs. Color

[melcooney]

I took this picture last fall and I felt it was missing something.

So then I reworked it in B&W with my photo editor and this is what I got.
What do you think?

 

[LaFoto]

Oh. The edit is not showing, well it is not to me. I get the colour version and a red x.
Have tried to gain access to it going "the scenic route" (i.e. by calling up the properties, then copying those, paste them into the communication line, open the site, and didn't get a thing.) Tried it through your own site, have seen all your family by now biggrin: ) ... but no black+white version. Hmph.

 

[melcooney]

Oh. The edit is not showing, well it is not to me. I get the colour version and a red x.... but no black+white version. Hmph.

Okay, I re-uploaded it and made sure I had the right URL...It is showing on my computer, so maybe it will show on yours now? (Hope so)

 

[JonK]

hmmmm... tough one. love the texture of thoe columns but I'm feeling a lack of contrast in both. gonna go for BW.

 

[Calliope]

Right now, I'm gonna have to say the color. If you bump up the contrast in the b&w one, I will definitely say b&w.