In honor of... CC

[Dillard]

No sir. Haha I am most definitely not the lighting expert around here. I'm sure someone will chime in. Was the flash direct or bounced?

 

[SharedMemories]

It was bounced off a wall that was to my left and behind me...

 

[wvsmphoto]

First of all I see nothing wrong with the photos the flag an the uniforms are NOT being disrespected this is a C&C not an ethics post I am a combat veteran and think that the photos were tastefully done.

The photos do have an orange tint to them if you have Lightroom 3 it is a very easy fix

Sent from my iPhone using PhotoForum

 

[Ballistics]

I'm not "offended" but as a vet I can tell you the last image can definitely be offensive to some(maybe even many) who have or are serving, especially since the flag is always carried and presented in a very organized and classy fashion where this image is the opposite of that. Definitely not "tasteful".

 

[Ron Evers]

Edit: I deleted this post as it was not related directly to photography.

 

[rexbobcat]

I don't really see anything wrong. I mean, your intent was not disrespect, and I think it's the intent that counts. I guess I'm not patriotic enough to become fussy over an issue that doesn't involve me. Or maybe I'm just sensible? Anyways...I like the 3rd photo the best. The lighting is good.I like the 1st one least. With both the girl and the flag tilted, the composition just seems off. Maybe if the flag wasn't parallel with the model?

 

[Iron Flatline]

It seems your white balance is a little off, the images look very "warm". A rim light to separate her from the background might have been a nice touch. The image where she is holding her shirt open doesn't really work. It implies a certain sexuality, but it comes off as clumsy. I don't mean that in a mean way, but it just doesn't work the way it was intended.

 

[JoeyV]

I also like the 3rd the best. You captured her in a great look/position. The way she is holding the flag shows emotion and love for it if you ask me. Holding something tightly close to your heart gives off a warm feeling from this image. As most have said, it does seem a little orange. Good shots though

 

[tom_anderson18]

I'll start my reply with I'm a beginner and have had a camera for a total of 3 days, now I like the pictures and apart from what has been said in regards to the orange tint I don't see a problem with them other than that I like them. As for people sayings its disrespectful then that is your opinion this isn't a place for an ethical debate of what is right and what is wrong, people have there own way of showing appreciation and thanks, if you personally don't like what was done then fair enough but don't start accusing people of what others do. I personally am proud of every single military person in whatever country, branch, job role, currently serving, veterans etc. They all do a brilliant job and do each country proud.

 

[Ballistics]

Holding something tightly close to your heart gives off a warm feeling from this image.

For starters, your heart is on the left side of your body, not your right. I see the flag being treated as a piece of laundry, like a towel or something. Or a bag of trash.

 

[Ballistics]

As for people sayings its disrespectful then that is your opinion this isn't a place for an ethical debate of what is right and what is wrong

2 things.

1) You are giving your opinion about others giving their opinion on the picture. You are telling people that they are wrong, for thinking the picture is wrong and then telling people this isn't the place to do that. Seem's a bit contradictory to me.

2) If someone has a picture of a confederate flag and a noose with a racial slur written somewhere and people were describing their disgust for the picture, would you still lecture others about how this isn't the place for an ethical debate?

 

[tom_anderson18]

1.) I never said that anyone was wrong, I said that it is someones opinion on whether they think it is right or wrong and that this isn't the place for an ethical debate.

2.) People can say whatever they like if its relevant to the thread, the OP was asking for C&C on the outcome of the images, if someone had done what you said posted a picture of a confederate flag and the noose, sure I may personally believe its inappropriate but I wouldn't start accusing the OP of what I personally believe.

 

[GeorgieGirl]

 

[cgipson1]

I would have to agree with Ballistics... I personally don't care for the shots.

Number one.. the "bedroom" hair, not something I would associate with a patriotic use of the flag...

Number two... if she is only 14, she has been watching way too much "bad" TV....

Number three... best of the set, but the use of the flag is somewhat offensive... it isn't a scarf, or a fashion accessory....

 

[Ballistics]

Shocking. Fulfilling your role, I see. And such hypocritical fashion as well.