I shot this guy about two or three weeks ago.
IMO, the afters all look too smooth and plasticy. What's your workflow? I hate skin smooth as there's a million different ways to do it, and sometimes some techniques work better than others.
What I would suggest is to bring back the opacity a bit in your smoothing layers, not a ton, but just a bit to give the model a more human look. People do have pores and such; removing them makes them look like dolls or mannequins.
HAHA! Small world VI! Was it the "wedding" theme shoot? Now that I think about it, I noticed your Flickr had a bride in it but I didn't look through and it didn't click then.
Yeah, w/ him, I just ran the action real quick and it did a little too much for him. I thought the black was a bit dark and the skin was a bit white once I was done but at midnight I was too tired to do it again. I will redo his shot.
I think it works better for certain people than other, like with my wife's skin and Kori's skin it looks more natural IMO.