Looking for C&C on photo

[mswiech]

New to photography and looking for people to C&C the photo's listed below. Thanks in advance!!

1.

2.

3.

4.

 

[greenjackson16]

sorry I can't see the photos

 

[Karri]

It's just red "X's" showing up...

 

[Bitter Jeweler]

Nice set!

 

[Trever1t]

you forgot the pics!

 

[xjoewhitex]

blown out. Sorry. lol

 

[mswiech]

Sorry everyone....pics are now posted Please provide your C&C

 

[greenjackson16]

1. its ok
2. great colors and angle
3. nice, my favorite. I'd like to see it without the black around the edges
4. would be cool if there were more color in the sky, and the flag doesn't line up right with the rest of the photo

 

[Trever1t]

The subjects are interesting but the composition isn't working.

 

[iNick]

im not diggin #1, its just uninteresting to me and the angle seems strange, #2 is sweet but i think a bit crooked (although it could be my eyes) #3 is awesome and #4 is uninteresting to me. good job with these my friend!
Cheers!
-Nick

 

[D-B-J]

The subjects are interesting but the composition isn't working.

+1

Regards,
Jake

 

[mswiech]

The subjects are interesting but the composition isn't working.

Can you explain more about your comment on Composition?

Thanks iNick, Trevor1t, Greenjackson16 and D-B-J for the comments.

 

[mswiech]

...

 

[wlbphoto]

so im new here and i asked this question on a different post but haven't got an answer. sorry if its a noob Q; whats C&C?

 

[Jeatley]

Comments And critique