The feel - so true. For me, there is also a flexibility with traditional media. I can vary the pressure and orientation of a brush, pencil, or piece of charcoal and get the line just-so. I can't seem to do that with software. I find the same thing, at times, when I'm working with GIS data; writing a Python script provides me a little more flexibility than the pre-built tools in the software, even though I call those same tools in my script.
For painting, I started with oils as a kid, and did a little watercolor, but not enough to really do well at it. I took an oil class during my first semester at community college, and hated it. It was more work than any other class I had, so painting became more of a chore than fun. I didn't pick up a brush for many years after that, though I did continue to draw a bit. It wasn't until 6 or 7 years ago that I started to play with painting again, but I went with acrylic and watercolor instead of oils.
Prismacolor are also my favorites, though I haven't tried their watercolor pencils, yet. I'll need to finish up the Derwent's I have, then I'll pick up some.
I am not quite the same with books - I love real books and magazines, but I also quickly adapted to e-readers - odd, I know, but it's partly because it's a physical space saver. I love my Kindle even though it's not what I would call a full blown tablet, just a reader with extra stuff.