Okay, so I finally saw the movie and can open this thread at last!
Poor acting: let us not forget that the acting or dialogue in the original three were really not very good either. It's no accident that Harrison Ford was the only one to go on and make am A-list career for himself. But the fact remains that the story - a very simple stripped down good-vs-evil...in space...story - draws us in and allows (most of) us to forgive the bad acting or little plot holes (like how stormtroopers can't hit the side of a barn except in certain scenes where the plot needs an accurate shot.)
As for Adam Driver, it was hard to stop seeing him as NOT Lena Dunham's boyfriend in "Girls."
Directing: I think JJ Abrams did with this movie the same thing he did with Star Trek, which was to keep enough of the original to keep that magic that made is special, while adding enough to make the story new. The prequels tried too hard and all the twists and turns and different characters complicated the story to the point that it was difficult to give a tiny rat's ass about them. This movie kept it spare again, kept it black and white so it was easy to choose sides and stay there. It's like that goggle lady said in the new version of the Mos Eisley cantina: when Rey asked what fight and she said something about how it's always the same fight. There are bad people who have too much power and who do bad things, and there are good people who fight them. And that's a real-world fight, not just a fantasy sci-fi fight. I mean, y'all DID get all the Nazi symbolism in the original movie and now in this one, right?
Writing: Ah yes, the whole woman behind every "great" man? Lucas alone was not responsible for the original three movies, and the fact that she wasn't around for the prequels might be evidence of him being a hack after all:
The secret weapon who made Star Wars great
This movie did seem a little rushed in a way, but it was also setting up the next two, and it gave us new characters to be invested in and care about. I thought they did a good job with the new cast. I don't think Poe or Finn are related to anyone, though I do think there might be a story behind Rey.
I avoided all spoilers until Buzz's nephew blurted out that Han Solo died just as I was telling to not say anything about the movie. (Yes, I'm still annoyed.) But he only spoiled
that Han Solo died, and now how he died, but once I knew it was coming, I saw all the hints adding up and I started bawling as soon as they landed on the planet to get Rey and lower the shields. I made sure I brought plenty of tissues with me.
I want to see it again. I saw the originals in the theater, including the very first one in 1977. I still remember how excited I was, and this movie felt very much like that. It concerns me that JJ Abrams isn't doing the other three, though
