Neither one works for me. They both could have except for details that I find annoying.
In #1 the two hands are lined up in such a way that you barely see the left hand. Just enough that I wondered what it was at first glance. I don't know that I'm explaining this right but hope you understand me anyway. lol.
With #2 it is the shadow on the wrist that kills it for me. Otherwise, with just a bit of your face in the frame, I like this image.