personally, i think certain members here are just trying to grasp at straws to defend their poor intentions in this circumstance. This is why the discussion has diverged into this.
I doubt anyone here cares about some random and exceedingly poor photographer enough to offer a genuine critique intended to teach. I still maintain that the sole purpose of comments made were to humiliate and bully. I wish you people would just admit that you were getting a kick out of making someone feel bad.
Because come on, we all do it.
you didn't make the comments, I did! Are you saying you know my intent? If so, How so? Are you psychic? A LSD vision maybe?
I did mention here a few times that I personally felt your comments on her FB page were pretty respectful, and very helpful. you literally commented on 3 different photos and explained not just "what" the issues were, but also "how" to correct them. (all while managing NOT to sound like a douche about it)
Hell, it was better C&C than a lot of what we get HERE when we are actually ASKING for it. If she DIDNT read that, and learn from it...its because she doesn't care about improving. (i obviously have NO insight as to the photographers mindset, it is mere opinion and speculation on my part)
