All the Nikkor 300/2.8 lenses are good performers. I went with the AFS-II, the one with the magnesium barrel, and thus lighter weight than its predecessor. The AFS-II model came out right before the original VR model. A few weeks ago, I looked at a CLEAN 300/2.8 ED AF-D, not an AFS model, but one of the screw drive ones, asking $1999, at walk-in retail. They also had a Canon 300/2.8 EF, not the latest model, but an earlier one for $2,000. The way to get a good deal on a 300/2.8 is to find one in a smaller, secondary market: NOT at
Adorama or
B&H or
KEH...those three stores all command the highest prices because of their reputation,return policies, and HUGE web presence. If you can do a bit of research, like buy a copy of SHutterbug magazine, you can develop a network of SMALLER dealers, located in secondary markets...look for a fair priced 300/2.8 to turn up in places like Seattle, Minneapolis-St. Paul, San Jose, Houston, Atlanta, Newark, Omaha, Kansas City, Oklahoma City, and so on...NOT from
The Big Five dealers.