Which edit on this shot do you prefer?

[NateS]

I've posted this on another forum with a general consesus.....everybody likes the shot, but nobody can decide how they feel about the sky or which edit is best. Please vote for your favorite edit to help me decide.

1. Yellow (my original edit)

2. Orange

3. Gray

4. Gray w/ just a touch of Red

Thanks, and feel free to post why you made your decision or general thoughts instead of just voting in the poll.

 

[porkphoto]

I'll pass on voting. I like the composition, I do not like the over saturated look. The photos look like it lingered in PS a tad too long. But please, that is just my own taste. You should develop yours as you like. Thanks for posting.

 

[beni_hung]

I'm not sure which way to vote, but I voted for the Grey with a touch of red.

 

[NateS]

I'll pass on voting. I like the composition, I do not like the over saturated look. The photos look like it lingered in PS a tad too long. But please, that is just my own taste. You should develop yours as you like. Thanks for posting.

Hmm...maybe the gray with a little less saturation on the foilage will work better. I might look at that.

 

[txphotog]

I prefer the 3rd one because it looks the most natural of the bunch.