Which treatment do you prefer?

Ron Evers

Been spending a lot of time on here!
Joined
Jun 28, 2008
Messages
6,631
Reaction score
2,588
Location
In the country 60km north of Toronto, Canada
Can others edit my Photos
Photos OK to edit
1.
P1010353-Edit - Copy-Edit.jpg



2.
P1010353-Edit - Copy-Edit-2.jpg
 
I prefer #1. It has a more natural vintage look to it. Silver tone, detail, and excellent composition. In #2, with highlight protection applied, caused halo effect in sky around edges.

Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk
 
I prefer the V.I.P. treatment...
In this case though, I like photo #1 more, for the reasons JC mentioned above.
 
#1 is my choice. It has a nice classic look and feel to it. The picture is timeless.
 
#1 is really nice.
 
Thanks all for your responses.

Looks like we are all in agreement. #2 brought out more detail but it looked "off" to me but I could not put my finger on it. JC showed me the light.
 
#2 makes me want to die.
 
# 1 for me

On # 2 the smoke looked weird. The blacks are no longer black but more of a dark grey. And then the trees look like it was taken more with a Full Spectrum camera then a regular camera.

I'm curious what it looks like with the right and bottom cropped up a bit while still keeping the Private Property sign which would enlarge the choo-choo and preserve your leading line with the tracks.
 
Now hold on just a second, partner...

If you are going for a more realistic look, then yeah #1 is your guy. But, #2 has an artistic quality to it that makes it look like a pencil drawing, and I LOVE that. Don't forget that photography is as much art as it is trying to catch a realistic shot!
 

Most reactions

Back
Top