you can find non-cubans that are as good. Cuba is the the ideal environment. But there are a few that come close, and in a few cases surpass the more average Cuban brands. It took a long time, and for a long time growers in other carribean countries didnt quite have the right mix, they had Cuban seed, but that seed really only worked in Cuba. Growers in other countries were actually better, but Cuba is a refined environment, that is ideal, and certain formulas are known to work there, through the ages. The seed needed to grow, and slowly morph into something that worked better for the soils, temperatures and sunlight exposure for the particular country the seed found itself in. Slowly the dominican had a few growers that have found a great mix that works for the climate. The problem these days isn't necessarily that good cigars aren't made in countries outside of Cuba, it's that advertising doesn't necessarily match quality of production. The truly great growers are growing all they can and thus have no interest in even trying to spend money to sell more.
Davidoff is a great cigar, pleasurable, dependable. Expensive, but you know you'll get a great smoke 9/10 times. The dominican Romeos are fine enough, exquisitely made, but with average seed for the environment. Gran Habano had a great thing going for a while with their #5 corojo, but have recently sold the line out and switched filler leaves. It's still a great smoke, but not quite as exquisite. A good Padron still rivals anything but the truly top of the line Cubans.
But to me, the big deal isn't particularly the smoke itself as much as the ritual. I can find plenty of pleasant enough smokes. The thing that turns it from something that is sort of okay for 10 minutes to something that transforms an hour of your life is the understanding of what a cigar is, why it differs from a cigarette, and appreciation of the whole thing. Maybe throw in a middle period Rolling Stones record and some good scotch and you got a winning combo.
While smoking this cigar, Gimme Shelter came up on my headphones (Sennheiser HD 650s). Merry Clayton sang on that track perhaps like nobody has sang before or since. Urban legend has it that Merry sang so hard, and with such fire on that track that she had a miscarriage later that evening. I dont know if that's true or not, but does the literal truth really matter in such a case? Listen to her voice crack when she sings "raaaaaape, murder, it's just a shout away" and that's all the truth I really need when it comes to that. You hear Mick Jagger in the background let out a visceral 'whoo" like he had never heard an emotional musical tone quite like that.
it's a sort of combination of rituals. I love vinyl, not because it's necessarily a better medium. Let's be honest, the Rolling Stones never really gave a crap about recording quality to begin with, but it's more the ritual of the whole aspect of the thing. When you're tossing a big heavy vinyl record on the table, you're committing yourself to something. The artist's vision in this case, a rolled bit of tobacco in another. where it takes your is your choice and their choice at the same time. Heck, so far as we know, somewhere back in the mists of time and legend a woman may have suffered great personal loss in the commission of such a ting. At least we can give it a bit of our time and maybe let out a soft 'whoo' of our own and appreciate what's been laid out on the table.