Worth it to pick up a Sigma 70-200?

[tirediron]

I'm pretty iffy with Sigma lens. While I haven't used the 70-200mm I have owned two other sigma lens and I've given them both away, they just weren't sharp. Based on my experience with both Sigma and Nikon I'd favor the Nikon every time.

Agree; the only Sigma I really want to play with is the 300-800 f5.6.

 

[SpeedTrap]

I was wondering if I should pick up a sigma 70-200 2.8

Sure you should pick it up, as long as you put it down soon after and go look at the Nikon Version..........

 

[KmH]

I've only owned one version of a Sigma lens, and it was a daytime field sports lens. I had 2 of the APO 150-500 mm f/5-6.3 OS zooms and for $999 new at that time, thought they were a great deal.

They have gone up a little in price Sigma 150-500mm f/5-6.3 AF APO DG OS HSM Telephoto Zoom Lens for Nikon Digital SLR Cameras

Both have now been replaced by 2 good used copies of the Nikon 200-400mm f/4G AF-S SWM SIC ED IF VR II Nikkor Super Telephoto Zoom Lens for Nikon Digital SLR Cameras I was able to get for a good price.

 

[AtlPikMan]

The Nikon Versions are better than the Sigma, Tokina or any other 3rd party lens. Will YOU be able to tell the difference...probably not. Will anyone be able to look at your shots and tell...If they are well focused, I doubt it. If you can patiently save and wait it out for a VR 1 by all means so, If not get the Sigma...You can always sell it and put the money towards the Nikon if you choose.

 

[Live_free]

My only problem with the nikkor model is that it is twice as much money, for slightly better sharpness.

 

[AtlPikMan]

My only problem with the nikkor model is that it is twice as much money, for slightly better sharpness.

Then that answers the question...Go for the Sigma, Im sure you'll be happy with it/ On another note I added you on Flikr.

 

[sierramister]

The Sigma is great. I have the 70-200 f/2.8 HSM II (non-OS), and it produces great images, little tone shifting, and is quick to focus. I paid $600 used for it, and it was basically untouched.

I figure there are enough people buying D3100's that I'll be able to sell it when I'm ready to upgrade to the the VRII Nikon version and not lose any money.

 

[Live_free]

I will look to buy the Sigma then. Thanks guys. :3

 

[pdq5oh]

My only problem with the nikkor model is that it is twice as much money, for slightly better sharpness.

Something someone mentioned when I was contemplating which 70-200 to buy. Focus accuracy, not just speed is important. And when the difference between a keeper and not, all things considered, the Nikon most likely will give you a higher keeper rate.

 

[Live_free]

Thanks guys. I am going to place an order for the sigma tomorrow. Any last minute pieces of advice are always welcome.

 

[480sparky39 38]

.......... Any last minute pieces of advice are always welcome.

Yeah.... buy two and send me one.

 

[Live_free]

I just ordered it. Should be here in a few days. Question to the pros out there, do you like using filters? Contemplating grabbing a polarizer for it. I have them for my other lenses, worth it to grab one for this lens too?

 

[djacobox372]

Considering you can buy a used Nikkor 70-200 f2.8 VRI for less, I would have to say no; not to me at least.

Agree,

And you could also buy a used 80-200mm f2.8 af-d for $500 or less. Which would be optically better then the sigma and even a little better then the 70-200mm VR1. Just no VR and a bit slower focusing.

 

[Trever1t]

I bought a used Nikkor 70-200vr1 a few weeks ago and can honestly say it's very fast fast focus on my D300s. The IQ is awesome and the build feels exceptional. I haven't seen one sell for less than $1400 around these parts although I did pick up mine for $1350.

As you've already ordered I hope the Sigma meets all your requirements. I'm happy I waited for the right deal and had saved up for the Nikkor....very much so.

 

[Live_free]

I hate buying used, and I am only 16. So the extra 600-800 is something I cannot afford as I have no job right now. Especially after just dropping 5k of my own money on a custom rig.

I can't wait for it to get here and play with it. Might pick up a polarizer if I deem it needed.