DRoberts
TPF Noob!
- Joined
- Apr 18, 2008
- Messages
- 779
- Reaction score
- 3
- Location
- Springfield, Missouri
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
My question is, why did this thread have to turn into another BS thread? The OP asked for simple C&C and it has turned into 4 pages of immature babble.
Yes there are specifics of the photos that would fall outside of "standardized correctness"...so state your opinion and move on. All we can do is state our opinion...no need to keep badgering. For every aspect that has been stated as being "wrong" with these photos, I can find several photographers who specialize in that very aspect of being "wrong"
"tilted and to soft"... maybe not tilted or soft enough.
" the wreaths seem to 3D, they pop out to much"...3 words...nuetral density filter. These are used all the time to lessen the brightness of one area of a photo to make another area (or subject) "pop out". Usually in outdoor settings to lessen the sky.
My point is getting on here with critiques that are nothing more than some generic recital of some rules that you have read or repeating what you have seen on here are in no way helpful to the people who are asking. If you are all knowledgable enough to tell the OP his work "sucks", then impress us and tell us how to make it better. Or do you know how to yourself?
Yes there are specifics of the photos that would fall outside of "standardized correctness"...so state your opinion and move on. All we can do is state our opinion...no need to keep badgering. For every aspect that has been stated as being "wrong" with these photos, I can find several photographers who specialize in that very aspect of being "wrong"
"tilted and to soft"... maybe not tilted or soft enough.
" the wreaths seem to 3D, they pop out to much"...3 words...nuetral density filter. These are used all the time to lessen the brightness of one area of a photo to make another area (or subject) "pop out". Usually in outdoor settings to lessen the sky.
My point is getting on here with critiques that are nothing more than some generic recital of some rules that you have read or repeating what you have seen on here are in no way helpful to the people who are asking. If you are all knowledgable enough to tell the OP his work "sucks", then impress us and tell us how to make it better. Or do you know how to yourself?