Well, I'm just saying that for a photograph to be successful, it needs to be more than a shot of a flower. I'm sure Derrel or Bitter or anyone more experienced than myself could write in lengths about this, and formulate that in a good, understandable way. I'm trying to say that if you press the shutter, something must have made you do that. Being artistic for the sake of "being artistic" isn't really something I like. I saw a video on youtube once, I think it was that Gavin guy, about shooting a flower on a plank, with a weird WB and heavy vignette from photoshop. I'm guessing several people went out into their back yard to shoot flowers on planks with weird WBs and with heavy vignette, but those photos do not mean anything. They did it because they saw a video on it, they initiate the shot by themselves due some something they felt.
I don't know why you really took that photo, other than "for practice", and I'm not sure what you practiced. If you had a "reason" for taking it, whether it was because you liked the contrast between flower on road, or because you wanted to convey an emotion of something, or something that might provoke some feelings in the viewer, then I'd understand it. I don't know how much time you put into the photo, either. For all I know, you may have put a flower on the road and snapped away just for the sake of "getting a cool pic of flower on road".
I'm not sure if I'm reaching through, here.
/opinion
First of all, I really do appreciate you taking the time to help, and also edit my photo. I DO understand where you are coming from, totally understand, comprehend what you are trying to explain. I agree that an image of a flower is boring, I NEVER photograph flowers, just yesterday, it was Valentines Day, so I thought it would be cool to do something with the flower I broke by accident. I mainly photograph people, like this one,
however, photographing people can be boring as well. I have a historic graveyard fascination, the one's that date back to the 17 and 1800's such as this one,
so perhaps a better photo would have been the broken rose on the old grave stone and a faded B&W as you did with my photo?? This historic grave yard is in my neighborhood and I'd like to get some better photo's of it. I did some research on this historic graveyard trying to find out who was buried there and found out they were slaves during the civil war era. I also have a facsination with OLD barns, the ones where roofs are caving in and old one-room school houses. I agree with you to some extent, but IMO, I do not believe a photo always needs to tell a
long story. I don't think there is anything wrong with simplicity.