Thank you all! The mom requested I try this "unnatural

" pose from one of my past sessions:
It's always a hit or a miss trying this pose!
But between the third pic in the OP and this pic (unfinished edit):
I think the third pic in the OP is better.
Sorry for digging this up..But I was going through posts today after all the recent drama..lol. Sabrina, I pulled this up because I wanted to ask something very important when I came across this. When you say the "pose is really hit or miss" do you mean that you're actually balancing the newborn's head on his little wrists???? Please say no...This is a huge and common mistake with new photographers, and I want to avoid you the upcoming lawsuits for injuring a newborn baby if that is indeed the way you are setting up this shot!
*never never never never* put the baby's head on his little wrists! Newborns are very weak and "bendy, " and their heads are the most disproportionately large/heavy parts of their entire bodies. You run the risk of seriously injuring a newborn if you pose this way.
Now, that disclaimer aside..the SAFE way to achieve the shot you're going for is to take TWO SEPARATE pictures and do a composite with layers in photoshop. You take one picture with mom holding babies head from the top, and one with mom supporting baby's chin. Then you merge them together so you don't see the hands in either image. That is the only way to safely do this pose.
If you knew that already and your first shot was indeed a composite, I apologize..but for ANYONE OUT THERE who may be wanting to copy this popular pose it's sooo vital to make sure people are educated about what is safe and what is not.
I worry just as much when I see the "hanging baby" poses, that somebody will actually try to hang a baby from a tree branch. Most of the time, baby is actually laying flat on an ottoman with the cloth positioned, or else baby is supspended less than 2 inches off the ground, with the canvas resized/cloned in photo shop to make it look higher.