Honest critique is something we've tried to encourage where we can and we are not opposed to it. Where the problem stems from is acceptance.
Many who give critique expect it to be accepted or followed; whilst those who get it do not always agree (for whatever reason). Critique should be a discussion process, where in each person can air their views and then offer the other side the chance to respond. They might not agree, they might disagree or debate back and that is part of the process. The two and fro shouldn't ever come to blows because its not an argument its a debate.
Sadly there are times where people (on both sides) get annoyed. Someone isn't accepting their viewpoint and things start to shift from debate into snide comments; or others jump in to "defend a friend" or viewpoint and again we start to have snide comments or a beat down of aggressive behaviour upon another member.
This is a mature forum for photographic discussion - users should not have to fend of attacks or beat downs and the whole "its the brutal honest truth" has nothing to do with it. It's about learning to talk with the written word in a polite and clam manner.
Its not unique to TPF and is a problem experienced on many larger communities. We CAN help fix it though - by leading by example as we mods attempt to do so and by having the key active members also do likewise. If you help you can be the solution.
i wanted to just quote this back to Overread in pm buy can't figure out how to copy/paste this in pm,so here goes....I think a problem message boards have in general is the fact that we blurt out the idea that we quickly formed...no inflection,no moment for interruption,etc.I stand by my thoughts that enforcement is haphazard,that OP's do a pretty good job,and that I hope Charlie does return.If you think it's odd that I say enforcement is haphazard,
and the OPs do a pretty good job,well,that's the way I see it.
IBTL