well..personally speaking, I have never been a fan of B&W, and I don't think either shooting in, or converting to B&W works for very many pictures at all. (this is of course, the same opinion many people have on selective coloring)
and yet, gsgary and the_traveler have shown me that sometimes, I just have to push through my natural prejudice against B&W and admit that a photo is in fact, just plain well executed.
my point is...just because something has become a cliche, or has been vastly overdone, (and usually poorly) does NOT mean someone cannot use that technique to produce a good image. if your going to throw selective coloring out the window due to misuse, you should toss sun flare out as well. and brick wall backgrounds. and train tracks. and desaturated images. and dutch tilts. and vignetting. and, well, you get the idea.