Fake look vs real! it's on!

[cobain]

Ok guys, what do you prefer and why?

Would you say this picture looks real or fake?
http://s3.amazonaws.com/data.tumblr...054660&Signature=8c71EYyjPI7Lg1JrzVBy0riLfR8= (it was one of my first hdrs so go easy also. P.s didnt have a tripod

 

[Bynx]

The guy moved between shots so there is a ghosting outline around him. I hope we arent being asked to compare one thing to another when really youre trying to find out if your 3D art work is up to snuff. For an HDR image the shadows are too saturated and filled in.

 

[nos33]

I prefer realistic with a hint of fantasy look about them if you are asking preference. And in your pic the person moved too much and he looks fake but the background looks real.

 

[cobain]

Was just talking about overall.

Also like i said i didnt have a tripod so it was just a quick picture i didnt mean to make him look 3d.